Democrats boycott Senate vote on FCC nominee Danielle Thumann Severs
Republicans push through FCC nominee Danielle Thumann Severs in Senate committee as Democrats protest process and raise concerns over her past work.
Senate Republicans on the Commerce Committee advanced Danielle Thumann Severs, President Donald Trump’s pick for the Federal Communications Commission, after every Democratic member of the panel skipped Wednesday’s vote in protest.
All 14 Republican senators, joined by Senate Majority Leader John Thune, filled one side of the committee dais. The seats for the 13 Democrats were empty. Committee chair Ted Cruz said he learned the night before that Democrats would boycott. Democrats said they had repeatedly pushed to pair the confirmation of Thumann, a senior counsel to current Republican FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr, with a Democratic nominee.
Dispute over process and balance
Cruz called the nomination routine. “This is an ordinary nomination to fill a vacancy previously held by someone in the same party,” he said. Cruz argued that the White House had moved forward with bipartisan pairs of nominees at other agencies, such as the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the Securities and Exchange Commission, and had not removed any Democrats from the FCC. He pointed out that it was within the president’s power to do so, as the Supreme Court had confirmed.
Democrats disagreed. Speaking to reporters outside the hearing, they said the process was anything but normal. The committee usually approves nominees to independent agencies like the FCC in bipartisan pairs to keep the balance between parties. If Thumann joins the commission, Republicans would hold three seats, with Democrat Anna Gomez remaining as the only member from her party. Gomez’s term has expired, but she can stay on until a replacement is confirmed. Democrats worry that confirming Thumann would allow President Trump to remove Gomez, since he would no longer need her presence for a quorum.
Democrats called for the vote on Thumann to be delayed until a Democratic nominee could be considered at the same time. Renominating Gomez would solve the issue, they said, but the White House has yet to put forward any Democratic names. “This is not a problem we created, but a problem that the White House can solve,” Democrats said in a statement. The White House did not respond to a request for comment.
Concerns over Thumann’s past work
Senator Ben Ray Luján sent a letter to Cruz asking for the delay, and raised questions about Thumann’s honesty regarding her work for Carr. At a November hearing, Thumann told senators she had “not worked with the Chairman on any media-related issues.” Luján pointed to documents obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request showing Thumann was involved with media matters. The documents indicated she helped draft commitments that led to FCC approval of the Skydance-Paramount merger and handled complaints about CBS’s 60 Minutes and public reaction to the Jimmy Kimmel controversy.
The FCC did not respond to questions about Thumann’s involvement. Luján said outside the hearing, “The questions that I have is if she was lying about this, what else is she lying about and what else is she hiding?” He called for both Thumann and Carr to appear before the committee before the end of the year. Luján, who supported Carr’s earlier confirmation, said he regrets that vote and wants the committee to consider using subpoenas or other measures to force answers. “Everything should be on the table here to be able to get answers for the American people,” he said.
Cruz acknowledged some discomfort about Carr’s handling of the Kimmel incident, which involved the FCC’s response after conservative activist Charlie Kirk’s killing. Still, Cruz said Thumann had cleared up concerns about her role. He pointed to his own JAWBONE Act, which would allow individuals to sue government officials who try to pressure companies into removing speech, as a way to protect free speech. Senator Jerry Moran said Thumann reassured him about her work at the FCC in a recent phone call.
Despite Democratic objections, all 15 Republicans present voted to advance Thumann’s nomination to the Senate floor, where it is expected to pass on party lines when scheduled. The clerk read the names of absent Democrats, but there was no response.