Telegram co‑founder Pavel Durov warned that Spain’s proposed online age verification rules and a ban on social media for those under 16 could expand government censorship, destroy online anonymity and enable mass surveillance. Announced this week, the measures risk turning Spain into a surveillance state, Durov said, even as they are billed as child protection.
Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez told the World Governments Summit in Dubai that Spain will adopt online age‑verification policies similar to proposals under discussion elsewhere in Europe, including the U.K. Sánchez described social media as a “failed state” and said tougher controls are needed to protect children.
The announcement prompted strong criticism from privacy advocates, cypherpunks and digital‑rights campaigners, who argue the rules would curb free expression and give governments broader powers to remove or block political content. On social media, critics suggested the real purpose of mandatory ID checks is control; some users said the measures would target people who expose government corruption. High‑profile commentators, including Elon Musk, mocked Sánchez’s proposal, while journalist Taylor Lorenz urged global resistance to online ID and age‑verification laws.
Some industry voices acknowledge the goal of protecting minors but warn current verification methods are counterproductive. Boris Bohrer‑Bilowitzki, CEO of layer‑1 blockchain Concordium, said mandatory checks are likely to push users to evade controls with VPNs, which obscure location and IP addresses by routing traffic through remote servers.
The dispute underscores a broader tension between safeguarding children online and preserving digital privacy and anonymity. Supporters of stricter rules say they are necessary to shield minors from harmful content; opponents say the same rules risk de‑anonymizing ordinary users, enabling censorship and expanding state surveillance powers.
Cointelegraph reiterated its commitment to independent journalism and encouraged readers to verify information independently in line with its editorial policy.